Skip to Content

Our Favorite Graham Cracker Crust Pie Recipes

Our Favorite Graham Cracker Crust Pie Recipes

If you’re looking for the best graham cracker pie crust recipes, then you’ve come to the right place. You will find my favorite pie recipes that can be made using a premade or homemade graham cracker crust.

I love the flavor and simplicity of making pies with a graham cracker crust. There are so many great recipes options which can be overwhelming. Lucky for you, I’ve tested hundreds of recipes over the years and will share the best of the best with you.

Best Graham Cracker Pie Crust Recipes

closeup of homemade cheese pie with strawberries

You will find options perfect for the holidays as well as simple summer, no bake pie recipes. So no matter what type of graham cracker crust pie you are in the mood for, you will find what you need right here.

Cherry Cheese Pie

cherry cheese pie with graham cracker crust

Maybe my most popular graham cracker crust pie recipe is this cherry cheese pie. Hundreds of readers have messaged me letting me know it is one of their all-time favorite pies.

And I have a feeling you will like it too!

It’s incredibly easy to make and is perfect for serving any time of year. All you need are four ingredients and a graham cracker crust!

Cherry Cheese Pie
smooth and creamy topped with delicious cherry pie filling
Check out this recipe
slice of no bake cherry cream cheese pie

Peach Pie

no bake peach pie with a graham cracker crust on table viewed from above

Looking for a traditional fruit pie you can make with your graham cracker crust? This no bake peach pie is another Treat Dreams reader favorite.

It brings together the delicious flavor of fresh peaches with just a few common ingredients. It’s super easy to make and one of my family’s favorites. I make this pie year-round for a special family dessert.

Peach Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
Simple no bake pie packed with amazing flavor. Ideal for any time of year.
Check out this recipe
no bake peach pie with a graham cracker crust on table viewed from above

Creamy Peanut Butter Pie

closeup of slice of peanut butter pie with a graham cracker crust

When you combine creamy peanut butter, cream cheese, and a graham cracker crust, you get a magical flavor!

This pie is rich and smooth, and easily one of my all-time favorite peanut butter pie recipes. It’s incredibly easy to make and no baking required!

Creamy Peanut Butter Pie
This pie has an amazing texture with a deep peanut butter flavor.
Check out this recipe
homemade peanut butter pie with a graham cracker crust

Blueberry Pie

top view of homemade blueberry pie using a graham cracker crust and fresh blueberries

Do you like fresh blueberries? Then you are going to love this recipe. It brings together just a handful of simple ingredients, but the flavor is incredible.

This is a great summer pie to serve at parties and get togethers. It’s a crowd pleaser, so be prepared to handle a lot of recipe requests.

Blueberry Pie
Simple but packed with flavor, this is a great fresh blueberry pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
top view of homemade blueberry pie using a graham cracker crust and fresh blueberries

Dutch Apple Pie

slice of homemade Dutch apple pie with a graham cracker crust on plate with fork

This wonderfully simple recipe brings together a classic Dutch apple pie filling with a graham cracker crust. And the results are so tasty!

This is a great twist on the traditional apple pie recipes out there, and it’s a great alternative for those who don’t like a traditional pie crust with their apple pie.

Dutch Apple Pie
Classic pie filling flavor with a graham cracker crust.
Check out this recipe
slice of homemade Dutch apple pie with a graham cracker crust on plate with fork

Banana Cream Pie

homemade banana cream pie on table

This is one of my husband’s favorite pies, it’s also another popular one with Treat Dreams readers. And if you are a fan of banana, I think you will agree.

This simple recipe combines cream cheese, bananas, and vanilla pudding for a wonderful texture and tasty flavor idea for any time of year.

Banana Cream Pie
Rich and smooth filling, this is a great pie for the holidays or any time of year.
Check out this recipe
top view of fresh made banana cream pie with graham cracker crust

Chocolate Chip Pie

overhead view of chocolate chip pie in pan and a slice of pie on a plate

This is the pie for the chocolate lovers. This old fashioned chocolate chip pie pairs so well with a graham cracker crust!

It uses more ingredients than many of the other recipes on this list, but the flavor it produces is well worth the effort.

This pie is one of my favorites to serve during the holidays. It’s incredibly flavorful, and unique making it a huge hit every year.

Chocolate Chip Pie
Rich and flavorful, this recipe is perfect for serving to guests.
Check out this recipe
chocolate chip pie in skillet style pie pan

Raspberry Cream Pie

picture from above of homemade raspberry cream pie

Before finding this recipe I had never made a raspberry cream pie. And ever since that first bite, this has been on of my favorite fruit pies!

The texture and flavor is wonderful while being simple to make. It’s a great last minute dessert pie that can be made any time of the year.

Raspberry Cream Pie
Deceptively simple to make while packing a lot of flavor.
Check out this recipe
picture from above of homemade raspberry cream pie

Eggnog Pie

slice of eggnog pie with a graham cracker crust on plate

Looking for a truly unique pie to make for the holidays? This pie produces a classic eggnog flavor with a creamy texture that is sure to be a big hit at your holiday get together.

This pie has become a Christmas tradition and I love making it for all those holiday parties every year.

Eggnog Pie
Creamy texture and classic eggnog flavor.
Check out this recipe
top view of eggnog rum pie on cutting board

Chocolate Mint Pie

overhead view of homemade chocolate mint pie topped with whipped cream

Chocolate and mint come together in this pie producing a big and tasty flavor. No mixes or shortcuts with this recipe.

This is the type of pie your grandmother made, and the flavor will not disappoint. If you take your chocolate pies seriously, you have to give this recipe a try.

Chocolate Mint Pie
The perfect balance of mint and chocolate, this pie can be made any time of year.
Check out this recipe
homemade no bake chocolate mint pie slice and whole pie with whipped cream

Strawberry Yogurt Pie

homemade strawberry yogurt cream cheese pie with slice taken out

I am not exaggerating when I say this pie may have the best texture I’ve ever made! The flavor is wonderful and the creamy texture makes an amazing combination.

If you like strawberries, then you’re going to love this simple to make pie.

Strawberry Yogurt Pie
Creamy texture and rich flavor, this is a great any time pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
top-view-of-homemade-strawberry-pie-with-yogurt

Chocolate Silk Pie

slice of homemade silk chocolate pie in foreground with whole pie in background

While I won’t say I’ve saved the best for last, I have to admit that this is one of my all-time favorite silk chocolate pies.

The rich and creamy filling is paired with a simple, homemade graham cracker crust (but you can use a premade if you prefer).

The flavor is classic, and I’m not sure if it could be improved. It’s that good.

French Silk Pie
Creamy and decadent flavor, this is the quintessential silk chocolate pie.
Check out this recipe
slice of homemade silk chocolate pie in foreground with whole pie in background