Skip to Content

Must Serve Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Must Serve Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

When it comes to Thanksgiving dessert, nothing beats out pie. And if you are looking for the best pies to serve with your Thanksgiving dinner, then you came to the right place.

I can’t even begin to tell you how many pies I’ve baked over the years for Thanksgiving. I’ve made everything from the classics to some interesting pies you may be surprised to hear about.

So if you are in need of a little Thanksgiving pie inspiration, read on for the definitive Thanksgiving pie roundup.

Traditional Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

top view of table decorated for Thanksgiving with pie and dessert

No Thanksgiving pie recipe list would be complete without these classic, delicious pies. In fact, these are the types of pies you will find served at most dinner tables.

But, not all recipes are made the same. For each of these classic pies, I will give you my favorite recipes so you can make one for your Thanksgiving dinner guests.

Pumpkin Pie

classic pumpkin pie on wooden table with whole pumpkins

Most will agree that you can’t have Thanksgiving dinner without pumpkin pie. The two go together like mashed potatoes and gravy, or turkey and stuffing, sweet potatoes and marshmallows, but digress…

So if you are planning to make a traditional Thanksgiving dinner, you cannot skip the pumpkin pie.

Luckily there are many great versions to make, so whether you want Grandma’s pumpkin pie, or a quick and easy recipe, I have you covered.

Classic Pumpkin Pie Recipe
Delicious traditional pumpkin pie perfect for your Thanksgiving dinner.
Check out this recipe
homemade pumpkin pie on holiday decorated wooden table
Bisquick Pumpkin Pie
Great tasting and quick, this is an awesome last minute pumpkin pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
homemade pumpkin spice pie with bisquick on table
Simple Pumpkin Pie
Great traditional flavor ideal for the whole family.
Check out this recipe

Apple Pie

top view of fresh baked apple pie on table

Easily the second most popular Thanksgiving pie, apple has that quintessential fall flavor perfect for any Thanksgiving dinner.

There are many wonderful recipes out there, and you can make your apple pie from fresh picked apples, canned, and even frozen.

The key to a great apple pie recipe is the spices. Below you will find my favorite apple pie recipes to serve during the holiday season.

Deep Dish Apple Pie
Perfect for the apple lovers, this recipe produces a great, spiced apple flavor.
Check out this recipe
overhead view of deep dish apple pie on wooden table with fresh apples next to it
Simple Apple Pie using Graham Cracker Crust
This pie is loaded with great flavor and texture, and since you won't need a homemade crust, it's super quick and easy to make.
Check out this recipe
top view of homemade apple pie with a graham cracker crust and crumble top on table
Fresh Apple Pie
Great tasting, classic apple pie ideal for Thanksgiving.
Check out this recipe
top view of fresh baked apple pie on table

Chocolate Pie

overhead view of homemade chocolate silk pie

This is a personal favorite of mine, and no traditional Thanksgiving dinner would be complete without a delicious chocolate pie.

Now, there are tons of different versions out there. So this is a great type of pie to go with a quick and easy recipe.

You can get an amazing flavor, without needing to invest a bunch of time when you’re already busy.

Quick and Easy Chocolate Pie from Cocoa Powder
Simple and incredibly delicious, this is my go to chocolate Thanksgiving pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
slice of homemade chocolate pie on plate with whipped cream and cocoa
Creamy Chocolate Mint Pie
Wonderful flavor and easy to make, this is a great Thanksgiving pie recipe everyone will love.
Check out this recipe
homemade no bake chocolate mint pie slice and whole pie with whipped cream
Traditional Chocolate Silk Pie
Great texture and flavor, this recipe is a classic.
Check out this recipe
overhead view of homemade chocolate silk pie

Pecan Pie

top view of traditional pecan pie on table

I absolutely adore a homemade pecan pie, and the earthy flavor of pecans is a true Thanksgiving classic.

One of the best things about pecan pie (beside the great flavor) is how easy they are to make. I always make multiple pecan pies for Thanksgiving get togethers and these recipes are always a huge hit with family and friends.

Old Fashioned Pecan Pie Recipe
Amazing flavor and texture, this recipe is a true Thanksgiving classic.
Check out this recipe
top view of old fashioned pecan pie with slice taken out of it
Simple Pecan Pie without Corn Syrup
Classic pecan pie flavor and no corn syrup needed. Easy recipe ideal for serving at Thanksgiving.
Check out this recipe
slice of classic pecan pie without corn syrup and whole pie in background
Classic Pecan Pie
Great flavor and texture, this is a traditional pecan pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
top view of traditional pecan pie on table

More Great Tasting Pie Recipes for Thanksgiving

top view of a variety of fruit pies on a rustic table

So what if you want to bake some non traditional pies for your Thanksgiving dinner? You’re in luck, I love mixing things up and baking interesting pies that break from the traditional holiday lineup.

So if you want to delight and surprise your Thanksgiving dinner guests, here are the perfect recipes for you.

Veggie Pies

top view of homemade sweet potato pie on wooden table

Since Thanksgiving is a traditional, harvest holiday, it makes perfect sense to use up all those delicious veggies and bake more pie!

If you’ve never tried a carrot pie or a sweet potato pie, you’re in for a treat!

Spiced Carrot Pie
Great flavor and texture, this pie is a tradition in my home.
Check out this recipe
slice of homemade carrot pie on plate
Traditional Sweet Potato Pie
Great flavor and texture, this is a wonderful pie for serving at Thanksgiving.
Check out this recipe

Fruit Pies

slice of blackberry pie on plate and whole pie viewed from above on table

This is one of the best alternative types of pie to bake for Thanksgiving. There are many wonderful recipes and combinations to choose from.

Fruit pies just have that cozy feel that everyone enjoys. Below you will find my all-time favorite fruit pie recipes, and each and every one of them is perfect for serving to your Thanksgiving dinner guests.

Easy Peach Crumble Pie
Sweet and delicious peach pie with a crumble top.
Check out this recipe
homemade crumble topped peach pie on table
Old Fashioned Peach Pie
Great, classic peach pie flavor. This is one of my personal favorite recipes.
Check out this recipe
overhead view of fresh baked old fashion peach pie
Simple Peach Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
Simple recipe with a big delicious flavor. Great last minute recipe.
Check out this recipe
no bake peach pie with a graham cracker crust on table viewed from above
Blueberry Pie using Frozen Blueberries
Great flavor and texture, this is a quick and simple recipe.
Check out this recipe
homemade blueberry pie with frozen blueberries
Simple Raspberry Pie using Frozen Raspberries
Another quick and easy recipe that is packed with great flavor.
Check out this recipe
top view of raspberry pie on table
Simple Pear Pie
Easy recipe using canned pears. Great flavor and traditional texture.
Check out this recipe
closeup of slice of pear pie on plate
Strawberry Pie using Frozen Strawberries
Simple and delicious pie ideal for strawberry lovers.
Check out this recipe
slice of strawberry pie on plate and whole strawberry pie in background
Traditional Blackberry Pie
Great flavor and texture, worth the extra time it takes to make.
Check out this recipe

Cream Pies

homemade raspberry cream pie on serving platter

The recipes below are some of the best tasting alternative pies you can make for Thanksgiving. They tend to be quite easy to make, but the flavor is absolutely amazing.

If you are a fan of chocolate cream pies or cheesecake, then you will love these recipes.

Banana Cream Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
Light and creamy, this recipe produces a wonderful flavor and texture.
Check out this recipe
top view of fresh made banana cream pie with graham cracker crust
Simple Banana Cream Pie using Pudding Mix
Quick and easy, this is an awesome last minute pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
slice of homemade banana cream pie with sliced banana
Easy Blueberry Cream Pie
Creamy texture and packed with flavor, this is a great Thanksgiving pie recipe.
Check out this recipe
top view of homemade blueberry cream pie
Easy Peanut Butter Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
Smooth and creamy, this pie is packed with flavor.
Check out this recipe
homemade peanut butter pie with a graham cracker crust
Crunchy Peanut Butter Pie
Creamy with a satisfying crunch, this is a family favorite in my home.
Check out this recipe
top view of homemade crunchy peanut butter pie topped with peanuts
Raspberry Cream Pie
Sweet and creamy, this pie is a huge crowd pleaser.
Check out this recipe
homemade raspberry cream pie on serving platter